“Who intercepted the letter, Martin? I want a name.”
Preston Calloway’s voice was cold as he stood beside the windows of his Michigan Avenue office. His attorney hesitated before placing a scanned document on his desk, a letter dated five years earlier that Naomi had written shortly after discovering she was pregnant.
The letter explained her condition and requested a private meeting with Preston. But what made his stomach tighten was the signature acknowledging receipt at the bottom of the final page.
Constance Calloway.
His mother had received Naomi’s letter, and she’d never mentioned it to him. Preston stared at her signature, remembering how frequently she’d criticized Naomi for being an ordinary schoolteacher who didn’t belong among Chicago’s wealthy families.
He immediately called Constance, barely waiting for her greeting before confronting her.
“Mother, did you know Naomi was pregnant when we divorced?”
A long silence followed.
“Preston, darling, there’s no reason to reopen unpleasant chapters of your life.”
“Answer the question.”
“That woman was going to destroy everything you’d worked for. You were preparing your first major national expansion, and you couldn’t afford distractions.”
Preston slowly rose from his chair, struggling to control his anger.
“What did you do with her letter?”
“I did what any devoted mother would do to protect her son’s future.”
For the first time in his life, Preston felt ashamed of the Calloway name. His mother hadn’t simply interfered with his marriage. She’d potentially stolen five years of his children’s lives from him.
Later that afternoon, Martin uncovered more details about Naomi’s circumstances. She taught science at a public high school on Chicago’s South Side, leaving her sons with a neighbor each morning before taking the train to work.
After the twins’ premature birth, Eli had required several medical procedures, forcing Naomi to reduce her working hours temporarily. Between hospital expenses, transportation costs, and loans she’d taken out to survive, she’d accumulated more than forty-two thousand dollars in debt.
Preston felt sick imagining everything she’d endured while he lived comfortably in a mansion large enough for an entire family. He wanted to help immediately, but he feared appearing at her apartment uninvited would only reopen old wounds.
Instead, he contacted a charitable foundation associated with his company. He arranged funding for a new science laboratory at Naomi’s school and explored additional financial assistance for struggling families, insisting that his involvement remain confidential.
He convinced himself that helping from a distance was the safest way to begin making amends. Unfortunately, Naomi discovered the arrangement when she overheard her principal speaking with a foundation representative.
“Mr. Calloway specifically requested that his name remain confidential.”
That evening, Preston’s phone rang, and Naomi’s name appeared on the screen for the first time in five years. He answered immediately, but her voice was colder than he’d expected.
“Are you trying to buy my silence now, Preston?”
“Naomi, I wasn’t trying to hurt you.”
“You’ve been hurting me for five years.”
Preston swallowed hard before admitting why he’d suddenly reappeared in her life.
“I know about Theo and Eli. I need to know whether they’re my sons.”
“Now you want answers? After everything you put me through?”
“My mother intercepted your letter. I only discovered it yesterday.”
Naomi fell silent, and when she finally spoke again, her voice trembled with disbelief.
“Preston, I didn’t just send you a letter.”
He gripped the phone tighter.
“What are you saying?”
“When the boys were born, I went looking for you at the hospital. Eli was critically ill, and I desperately needed you beside me.”
“Naomi, nobody told me you came.”
“Your mother told me you’d personally ordered everyone to keep me away from you.”
Preston covered his face, realizing the deception had continued even after his sons were born. But Naomi had one final revelation.
“And before you think about coming to our apartment, there’s something else you should know.”
“What is it?”
“Eli found a photograph from our wedding. He asked me why the man standing beside me has exactly the same eyes as him.”
Preston couldn’t speak. Somewhere across Chicago, a little boy was already beginning to wonder why the stranger in his mother’s wedding photograph looked so much like himself.
PART 3: THE FATHER THEY NEVER KNEW
Preston spent most of the night sitting inside his car outside Naomi’s apartment building on Chicago’s South Side. The aging brick structure had narrow balconies, peeling paint around the entrance, and none of the comforts found in his nine-thousand-square-foot mansion in Lake Forest.
